Lively Run Farm is wedged between Cayuga and Seneca Lakes in the heart of New York State's Finger Lakes Region. It was one of the first commercial goat dairies in New York State when it opened in 1982, and was best known for its French-style chèvre and Mediterranean Feta. In 1995 the farm was bought by Steve and Suzanne Messmer. Suzanne soon began making Cayuga Blue.
While it was initially conceived as a goat milk version of classic French Roquefort, over the years Cayuga Blue has developed a unique identity. Steve and Suzanne's son, Peter Messmer, is now a cheesemaker at Lively Run. In producing Cayuga Blue, his goal is to make a well-veined, natural-rinded blue cheese that is both subtle and complex. Ideally it's mellow, nutty and earthy, complemented by notes of Portobello mushroom and the slight spiciness of the P. Roquefortii mold. Because it's made with goat's milk, the blue mold tends to be less sharp than it might be in a cow's or sheep's milk blue, although the flavors of goat milk are often quite pronounced.
Cayuga Blue is aged for at least two months, and is normally made from pasteurized milk, although Peter occasionally makes batches with raw milk for special orders.